2010 Comprehensive Carnegie Mellon University
When Jared Cohon received the Carnegie Corporation of New York’s Academic Leadership Award in 2005, there was no shortage of worthy academic pursuits on which the Carnegie Mellon University (CMU) president could spend the accompanying $500,000 prize. He chose to direct a large sum to a Global Awareness Across the Curriculum initiative, in which faculty from the institution’s six undergraduate colleges vied for grants to create new courses exploring international topics and themes. It achieved the desired results. An engineering professor won a national award for a project management course in which students in Pittsburgh collaborate with counterparts in Brazil, Israel, and Turkey. Information technology students teamed up with classmates in Qatar and students in Singapore to design Web sites for NGOs. In classes held synchronously and linked by video in Pittsburgh and Qatar, an architecture professor explored the challenges posed by the construction boom in cities in the Middle East.
A n international bent comes naturally to Carnegie Mellon, a private university founded in 1900 by the Scots-born steelmaker and philanthropist Andrew Carnegie to teach “practical arts and sciences.” CMU is a bastion for computer science and for engineering and technology, but is also home to a celebrated fine arts program. It boasts not only of Nobel Laureates (16), but also of winners of Academy Awards (56) and numerous Tonys and Emmys. Both mathematician John Nash of A Beautiful Mind and artist Andy Warhol are alumni. Its labs have done pioneering work in artificial intelligence, robotics, and biometrics. Those breakthroughs occurred on the home campus in Pittsburgh, three miles from where the Allegheny and Monongahela meet to form the Ohio River. But today CMU has a wider footprint, with graduate programs in more than a dozen countries and a full-fledged undergraduate branch in Qatar.
One of Six U.S. Universities in Qatar
Carnegie Mellon Qatar is one of the six U.S. universities—the others are Weill Cornell Medical Center, Texas A&M, Northwestern, Virginia Commonwealth, and the Georgetown School of Foreign Service—offering degrees in the oilrich emirate’s Education City in Doha. Carnegie Mellon Qatar occupies a striking new building with golden interior walls on which are etched the words of Andrew Carnegie that serve as the university’s motto: “My heart is in the work.” A bagpiper in full Scots regalia played at the February 2009 ceremony where Sheikha Mozah Bint Nasser Al Missned, wife of the Emir and chair of the Qatar Foundation, and Cohon shared ribboncutting duties. The student body, half Qatari and half international students, is small (300) but growing, with roughly 35 graduates each year. It offers bachelor of science degrees in business administration, computer science, and information systems.
“If you spent enough time here in Pittsburgh to get the essence of Carnegie Mellon and then went to observe our program in Doha, you would say, ‘Gee, this really is Carnegie Mellon.’”
Carnegie Mellon, with unstinting support from the Qatar Foundation, has striven to replicate in Doha the educational offerings and the cocurricular experience afforded in Pittsburgh. Some faculty are hired from the region, but others such as Kelly Hutzell and Rami el Samahy from the School of Architecture alternate semesters’ teaching in Pittsburgh and Doha. Hutzell calls it “a joy” to be teaching her “Mapping Urbanism” course in a city undergoing dizzying changes. Carnegie Mellon deans and department heads visit Doha regularly and there is a brisk, two-way traffic of students on breaks, over summer and for full semester stays. Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton and Bill Gates have spoken at events hosted by Carnegie Mellon Qatar.
“If you spent enough time here in Pittsburgh to get the essence of Carnegie Mellon and then went to observe our program in Doha, you would say, ‘Gee, this really is Carnegie Mellon,’” said Cohon, a civil engineer who has piloted Carnegie Mellon since 1997.
Surging International Enrollment
The number of international students has doubled over the past decade, from 1,747 in fall 1999 to 3,518 in fall 2009. They constitute almost half the graduate student population and are strongly represented in engineering, management and information systems, computer sciences, and business.
Carnegie Mellon prepares undergraduates for careers in engineering, arts, humanities, and sciences. Many of these professionally oriented majors have requirements that can make it difficult for students to fit education abroad into their schedules. Some 400 now take some of their coursework overseas, and that number has been rising. “Study abroad in the usual semester abroad sense is sometimes a hard sell,” said Linda Gentile, director of the Office of International Education. This reality has strengthened the determination of faculty and administrators such as Vice Provost for Education Indira Nair to find other ways for students to, in Nair’s words, “become aware, socially responsible global citizens.” This includes innovative uses of technology to expand the classroom well beyond the confines of Pittsburgh and arranging unusual summer internships in faraway places for CMU’s technologically adept students.
A Memorable Lesson in Concrete
Lucio Soibelman, professor of civil engineering, codesigned the award-winning construction project management class taught synchronously with engineering schools in Brazil, Israel, and Turkey. His share of the president’s Carnegie award paid for digital equipment that allows students in all four countries to see everything that Soibelman writes on a whiteboard in Porter Hall in Pittsburgh. Soibelman isn’t teaching basic engineering skills—these advanced students are well beyond that—but he is equipping them to overcome the cultural barriers that working engineers confront daily on international projects. “The main readings and discussions are related to globalization. They read books on working across cultures and on negotiation,” said Soibelman, a native of Brazil.
His students once got into a friendly quarrel with their Turkish counterparts over how quickly concrete could be poured. “The Turkish students kept saying they could build one floor per week. The American students kept pushing back, saying, ‘No, you can’t,’” recalled Soibelman. One floor a month is the U.S. norm. But when the Americans flew to Turkey on spring break, the Turkish students immediately brought them to a construction site where concrete was being poured. A week later, before the return flight, they returned to see the next floor going up. “When I asked my students how the trip was and what sights they had seen, they just looked at me and said, ‘They can do it,’” recalled the professor, who explained that lower labor costs, greater use of concrete, and major investment in concrete forms allow the Turks to build more rapidly.
“We want every student to have a global perspective and be able to use their expertise to solve real world problems (across) disciplinary boundaries and national boundaries.”
Globe-Trotting Student Consultants
Joseph S. Mertz, Jr., who teaches in both the School of Computer Science and the graduate H. John Heinz School of Public Policy and Management, places students each summer on internships as technology consultants in Micronesia, the Cook Islands, Palau, India, and elsewhere. “I teach geeks the soft skills they need to put their technical skills to use in the service of humanity,” said Mertz. CMU undergraduates helped the Republic of Nauru issue national identification numbers to its 10,000 inhabitants. Two students helped the tiny island of Niue, the smallest selfgoverning country in the world (pop. 1,400), connect laptops to the internet for its 500 schoolchildren. At a Bangalore, India, orphanage for blind children, students wired a computer to a traditional Braille machine, sounding out the letters and words children wrote with a stylus and correcting their spelling.
In the Global Project Management course taught by Randy Weinberg, director of the Information Systems (IS) program, students in Pittsburgh and Doha collaborate with students at Singapore Management University. “They do video, they Skype, they e-mail. We have the same readings, assignments, and assessments,” said Weinberg. It is a taste of the life they will lead when they graduate “because unless you’re a small, boutique IS shop, your clients and partners are going to be in distant locations.”
The culture at Carnegie Mellon is highly interdisciplinary. Partnerships are encouraged with colleagues across campus and around the world. “We want every student to have a global perspective and be able to use their expertise to solve real world problems (across) disciplinary boundaries and national boundaries,” said Amy Burkert, an assistant science dean who designed and taught one of the global courses and recently succeeded the retiring Nair as vice provost for Education.
Branding Carnegie Mellon Overseas
Doing what Carnegie Mellon is doing in Qatar is daunting, but there has been widespread agreement that “getting the Carnegie Mellon brand out into the world was an adventure worth pursuing,” said Provost Mark Kamlet.
Students from Pittsburgh are encouraged to spend a semester in Doha, and 10 are sent over spring break on a trip paid for by the division of student affairs in Pittsburgh and Qatar Foundation. Fifty students vie for those slots, and those chosen are expected on their return to share the experience with peers.
Megan Larcom, 21, a senior from Middletown, Rhode Island, majoring in international relations and business administration, interned in the Doha student affairs office the summer after freshman year, then returned to Qatar for a full semester as both a student and teaching assistant in accounting classes. A varsity rower with a 4.0 GPA, she also played on a newly formed women’s basketball team in Doha. She twice won federal scholarships to spend summers studying Arabic in Tunisia and Morocco, then landed a Fulbright scholarship to Egypt, where she is teaching English and pursuing research at Suez Canal University.
Student Affairs in Qatar
That student affairs office in Doha has a staff of ten, larger than any of the other U.S. universities in Education City, said Renee Camerlengo, assistant dean of student affairs and director of special projects in Pittsburgh. “From the very beginning we really believed in a very strong out-of-classroom experience” for the Doha students, most of whom commute to classes, said Camerlengo.
While Qatar is regarded as a progressive and tolerant place, Camerlengo asks the American students to dress conservatively and not drink alcohol while living in the Muslim country “as guests of the Emir and the Sheikha.” On their return, students are expected to share what they saw and learned. “We’ll never be able to send all 5800 (undergraduates) to Doha on this kind of trip, so the students fortunate enough to go have to bring a part of that experience back to their contemporaries,” Camerlengo said.
Opportunities and Pins on a Map
President Cohon said the expansion of Carnegie Mellon’s global footprint has not been “as strategic as we would like. If we took a map of the world and put pins on the countries we would like for Carnegie Mellon to be present in…. It would be China and India first, and then maybe other places after.”
But CMU planted its flag in the Middle East when the Qatar Foundation pledged to furnish the facility and cover most other costs. “Where we are is very much a product of our taking advantage of opportunities that have arisen and respecting the constraint we have self imposed, which is that we will not subsidize any international program from Pittsburgh. They have to pay for themselves,” said Cohon. “We are not a rich university.”
Cohon wants Carnegie Mellon to be recognized “as an important institution and indispensable institution in those new centers of wealth and power.” And he wants the university community to look back in 2050 and say, “Gee, it really was a great thing that we decided to become a global university 50 years ago.”